Topper Copies

2. (c) 'A nation loses control over money supply under fixed exchange rate regime with perfect capital mobility (at constant prices), thus making monetary policy completely ineffective in changing output. However fiscal policy is fully effective in this case'. Do you agree? Explain.

Tarun Pawar, AIR 311, 2025

According to 'monetary trilemma' or 'impossible trinity', a nation with fixed exchange rate and capital mobility does not have control over its money supply.

[triangle with corners: Fixed exch. rate, Capital mobility, Flexible exchange rate, Monetary control; side notes "Loss of monetary control" and "Restricted capital flows"]

This can be explained using Mundell-Flemming framework :-

[Mundell-Fleming graph with interest against Y: horizontal BP at i = i_f, IS and LM intersecting at E0, LM shifted to LM' and a new equilibrium E1, output Y and Y1]

- Assuming perfect capital mobility, as money supply increases, it shifts LM curve right. - we reach new equilibrium E1.. However, at E1, we have persistent BoP deficit. - Thus, central bank intervenes to maintain exchange rate at its fixed level. It reduces money supply →(and inject $ in economy) and we are back at our original equilibrium E0.

Thus, monetary policy is completely ineffective in changing output and actions of central bank are bound by its commitment to keep exchange rate at its fixed level.

Fiscal policy case

[IS-LM-BP graph with LM and LM1, IS and IS1, equilibria E0, E1, E2, output Y and Y1]

- Fiscal expansion leads to higher interest rate. -> increased capital inflows - To prevent appreciation of currency, central bank increases its forex & expand domestic money supply.

As a result, output is increased from Y to Y1. Thus, fiscal policy is completely effective.