Topper Copies

The booklet prints no question (question 2); the answer is written to the question of why monetary and fiscal policy are ineffective in the classical model.

Mohit Aggarwal Nadbaiwalla, AIR 281, 2025

Classical model envisaged any monetary and fiscal intervention is totally ineffective, thereby unnecessary,

Fiscal Policy Effect:-

[two graphs: an AS-AD graph with a vertical AS and AD', AD° and AD'' shifting right, on price and output (y); and a loanable fund market graph with interest rate i1, i2 against output y0, with lines I+G' and I+G° and points A, B, C]

(AS & AD Curve equilibrium) [Loanable fund market]

Any fiscal (expansion) [contraction] will raise demand for loanable funds i.e. raise interest rate, i1 to i2, which will raise the cost of capital for industries and opportunity cost of holding money for Household. :. Industries will reduce their investment by CD amount and Household investment by CD amount and Household will increase savings to A+B. This will negate the effect of fiscal expansion and output will remain same at y0. There will be change in nominal interest rate (Fisher equation) and price, no real output change. making fiscal expansion ineffective.

[Monetary Policy] : change in money supply will shift AD curve as in fig (1), which will raise the prices, and due to perfect wage-price flexibility there will be full employment at 'L0' level (as earlier) ∴ No change in real employment level and overall output.

[a labour market graph with nominal wage w1, w2, supply curves Ls1, Ls2 and demand Ld1 shifting to Ld2 = MPL.P2, with the boxed note w1/P1 = w2/P2]

as workers revise their wage Supply due to rise in price and price induced labour demand ⇒ monetary policy ineffectiveness

Therefore, fiscal policy (dd) side and monetary policy is ineffective even in short run.

However there could be supply side impact of fiscal policy (tax cuts) in labour supply which will increase labour and output,