Compare and contrast the key assumptions and policy implications of neo-classical and neo-Keynesian economic theories.
Mohit Aggarwal Nadbaiwalla, AIR 281, 2025
Neo-classicals and neo-keynesians are macro-economic theoretical frameworks given to understand role of Business Cycle and Government intervention.
Both gave their different modelling
1. for 'short-run', frame - Neo-Keynesians (Hicks & hansen) though gave importance both money and foods market via 'IS-LM model' - 'Neo-classicals' explained short run changes through 'AD-AS'. 2. Neo-Keynes did not give any role to expectations, which solely based on money demand of Keynes (Ky-hi) and exogenous money supply (ms). Neo-classicals incorporated friedman's money demand function, which is more elaborated than 'lumpy' keynes. 3. For neo-keynes, role of 'fiscal policy' is seminal to correct disequilibrium, for neo-classicals 'fiscal policy' does not play much role even in short run, they thereby gave more value to monetary policy. 4. In Neo Keynes, prices are stable in short run, but neoclassicals, prices are variables based on expectations. 5. In long Run, Keynesian does not explain because they say "In long run, we are all dead" while neoclassicals always natural rate of output and employment in long run, with adaptive expectation correcting any disequilibrium, and any initial change done by unwanted policy intervention is squared off.
Both though, prescribed policy suggestion
1. In short run, to minimise business cycle fluctuation, policy intervention could be helpful. 2. If excess - capacity exists, then neo-Keynes IS-LM framework suggest 'pump-priming' to reach at Jn. 3. In long run, however, structural changes like Building infrastructure, Building human Capital and ensuring Institutional integrity will help.
Both view, further developed by New Keynesians and neo-classicals respectively