Topper Copies

Compare the life-cycle hypothesis with Permanent income hypothesis. In what ways are they similar and different?

Mohit Aggarwal Nadbaiwalla, AIR 281, 2025

Life cycle hypothesis given by 'Modigliani' postulates that an individual will consumes accordy to the incomes received during his life-time and wealth.

The Consumption depends on not only present level of income but also 'Expectation' of future income. An individual, having life expectancy of '75 years', will Consumy by 'borrowing / parental assets' till 25 years, and from Age '25 - 60', he will earn more and Consumes less and produce savings which will be dissaved post retirement till his death.

[a graph of income and consumption against age, marked 0, 25, 60, 75: a hump-shaped income curve and a roughly level consumption line meeting at points e and e' at ages 25 and 60, hatched areas between them; legend "where C, C' -> Consumption line, I°, I' -> income"]

Permanent Income hypothesis (PIH), by milton friedman, however, talks of the 'permanent income an individual' get' over life time, not factoring in any Temporary income of non-permanent nature.

Similarity 1. Both hypothesis focused on expectation of income in future 2. Both assumes perfect information about the age they are going live and the income, level of credit etc. 3. Both assumes that any change in income in short run will not affect marginal propensity to consume as income will be distributed over-life time. => Rigid mpc'

Differences 1. In lifecycle hypothesis (LCH) all temporary or permanent wealth and income is incorporated unlike 'PIH', where only permanent income matters. - ∴ eg:- transfer payments due to recession will not affect 'PIH' policy conclusions, but Life cycle hypothesis will affect mpc. 2. Ricardian equivalence is not valid in case of LCH, as rise in income today, will be offset tomorrow by rise in Tax liability but in PIH, Ricardian equivalence operates; consumers will revise their consumption.

Both LCH and PIH assumes rational behaviour of consumers and household and reject behavioural factors, 'impulses', role of nudge and animal spirits along with changing societal preferences with progress.