Topper Copies

Explain how Keynesian speculative demand for money is restated in regressive expectation model. Point out its limitations.

Mohit Aggarwal Nadbaiwalla, AIR 281, 2025

Keynes unlike classical theorised the speculative demand for money, which is based on return of/from & investment on 'bond'.

Any money held with/ demanded will depends on prevailing interest rate. this he therised using his regressive expectation model.

He maintains ÷ there are two ways that money could be earned via speculation : i.e.

1. 'capital gain' due to price rise of bonds 2. 'interest rate' gains.

A person / economy will hold money as long as the net return is zero or negative ,

This he termed a critical interest rate 'ic'. Any rate above will lead to full investment in bonds and any rate below ic will be full money demand

suppose price of bond is Pb, 'y' is return.

i' = y / Pb

'i'' interest rate.

and for capital gains (g)

g = (Pb^e - Pb) / Pb { Pb^e expected price }

rewrite as (Pb = y/i) and (Pb^e = y/i^e)

g = (y/i^e - y/i) / (y/i) => (i - i^e) / i^e

Total gains = i + (i - i^e)/i^e

If total gains = 0 to find ic.

i + (i - i^e)/i^e = 0 => i i^e + i - i^e = 0

=> i = i^e/(1+i^e)

[a graph of interest rate against money: a horizontal line at i_c from the interest rate axis meeting a vertical line down to the money axis, the liquidity trap shape]

Any rate above i_c will lead to full investment in Bond and below i_c will be no money demand

this is what happened during liquidity trap of great depression.

Limitations →

1. Did not explain the 'mix' of both Bond and money demand which is counterintuitive by his own admission (Transaction dd) 2. 'Lumped' returns on money investment in 'bonds only' which is Improved by Baumol, Tobin and friedman 3. did not tell what will be the value of 'i_c'

However, Keynes regressive expectation model is a further step in evolution of theory of money demand on which future economist developed

[a graph of i against money: a curve falling steeply from the top, flattening, then dropping sharply near the right end]