Distinguish between monopolistic and monopsonistic exploitations in determining wage rate under imperfect competition.
Mohit Aggarwal Nadbaiwalla, AIR 281, 2025
'Monopolistic' exploitation is due to product market monopoly when wages are paid = MR.MP_L rather than VMP_L (P.MP_L) and 'monopsonistic exploitation' is due to existence of monopsony (single buyer and many sellers) in labour / factor market.
[a labour-market graph, Labour on the x-axis and VMP/ASC, MRP_L, ME, wage on the y-axis: downward VMP_L and lower MR.MP_L, upward S_L = ASC, dashed ME/MRE above it, equilibrium points e0, e1, e2, e3 with wages w1, w2, w3 and labour L1, L2, L3]
'w3,' wage when perfect competition in product market
w2 → wage when perfect competition in factor market
This could be understood with help of above diagram. If monopsony in factor market exists, supply of Labour (ASL) will not be the marginal expenditure curve of the monopsonist, it would be above i.e. 'ME'
on the other hand, wages will be paid according to MRPL if market imperfections exists in product market.
In such case, ME would be equated to MR.mPL (MRPL) to reach the equilibrium labour level, and wages would be paid as 'W1', not W3 as in case of monopoly and Perfect Competition in factor market
The exploitation (w₁-w₂) is due to monopsony as w₂ is wrye rate if Perfect Competition would exist in factor market and (w₃-w₂) is monopolistic exploitation by equation (S_L = VMP_L)
if both did not occur, Labour would be paid = w₃ and employment would be L₃.
Chamberlin however differs, in the sense that he did not term this as monopolistic exploitation and in his view only monopsonic exploitation would occur as workers are not paid = MPL = MRPL.