Topper Copies

Compare the Kaldor-hicks criterion with the pareto criterion in assessing changes in welfare due to a new policy.

Mohit Aggarwal Nadbaiwalla, AIR 281, 2025

'Pareto criteria' given by V. Pareto that in a perfect competition situation Maximise the welfare and from there is no possibility of deviation. i.e. No one can't be make better off without making other worst off.

'Kaldor-hicks' went a step ahead and said that if economic progress is such that one is made better off and other is worst off, and Better off can Compensates the losers (Kaldor), or loser can't Compensate the winner then, (Hicks) then society will be better off.

[a utility possibility frontier graph, Utility B against Utility A: a UPF curve with points T, P, R and Q along it and point S inside it, with arrows from S towards T/P, R and Q]

if economy is initially at point S. Any new policy, suppose Aatmanirbhar bharat, move the economy from point 's' to point 'p', 'R', 'q' it would be considered as Pareto improvement, as in case of P or q B(A) is made better off without making A(B) worst off. and R is making both A and B better off.

However, if new policy shift s to 'T', it would be loss to 'A', which Pareto did not consider an improvement,

Here Kaldor-Hicks' principle comes handy. They maintained that it is possible that improvement happened as from 'T'; there is possibility that B can compensate 'A' by ready to point like 'X' therefore, economy as a whole improved.

there difference could be summarised as follows :-

| Pareto | Kaldor-Hicks | |---|---| | Real improvement of welfare through distribution | potential distribution, in reality this might never happen ... Rising inequality with growth. |

- (MRS)^A_xy = (MRS)^B_xy = (MRT) - (MRTS)^x_{yk} = (MRTS)^y_{lk} - (MRT)_{x,y} = Px / Py - It is improved by Skitovsky by giving double criteria and Reversal test

Both Pareto and Kaldor-Hicks are production side theory, which does not talk About distribution much A.Sen, improved upon this.