State Marshallian and Walrsian stability condition of market equilibrium. Do you think that existence of Marshallian stability necessarily ensures Walrasian stability and vice versa? Explain.
Mohit Aggarwal Nadbaiwalla, AIR 281, 2025
A. Marshall (Principle of economics) is a Partial equilibrium model, where quantity adjustment based on willingness to pay and willingness to sell take place.
Walrasian general equilibrium, however is a 'price adjustment model' based on Excess demand or excess supply based on exit or entry of firms Respectively.
In 'normal' demand and supply curve both marshallian and walrasian dd curves are 'stable'.
[two graphs of price against output with an upward S and downward d: 'stable marshall' with WTP>WTS left of equilibrium and WTP<WTS right of it; 'Stable walras' with Excess supply above and Excess dd. below]
However, this is not always the case.
[four graphs of price against output, each with S and d crossing: both downward-sloping with S flatter or steeper, and both upward-sloping with S flatter or steeper]
| Condition | Marshal | Walras | |---|---|---| | es>ed / es>0 / ed ; ed>es | unstable / stable | stable / unstable | | es<ed / es<0 / ed ; es<ed | stable / unstable | unstable / stable |
The stability and unstability in both marshal and walras are different when normal curves does not exist.