Topper Copies

The booklet prints no question; the answer is written to the question of how the cardinal marginal utility approach and the indifference curve approach each explain the demand curve, and what the advantages of the indifference curve approach are.

Mohit Aggarwal Nadbaiwalla, AIR 281, 2025

Marshallian Utility (The Cardinal - additive approach) and Hicksian Cardinal - Indifference curve) can explain demand curve.

marginal utility approach via law of equimarginal utility (Utility derived from last ₹ spend is same for all goods and equal to marginal utility of money MUm)

MUx/Px = MUy/Py = MUm → marginal utility approach.

[a graph of price against quantity with curves MUx/Px and MUx/Px' and a horizontal line MUm, and below it a downward-sloping demand curve]

While I.c. approach is based on ordinal preferences based on ranking of bundles and assumption of transitivity, reflexivity and completeness.

[an indifference curve and budget line diagram, and below it a price-quantity graph with a downward-sloping demand curve]

no marginal utility concept IC approach

Advantage of IC cum approach

1. Assumes little and explain more Compared to marginal utility approach, which Considers MUm is Constant (Unrealistic), and utility to be additive (Cardinal) 2. IC approach explain both substitution (SE) and Income effect (IE) of price change while marginal utility approach only Considers S.E., not I.E. 3. IC approach can be applied in welfare economics, while marginal utility approach has very little practical utility 4. IC approach Can explain behaviour in Inferior / veblen / Giffen goods, while marginal utility approach could not.

Therefore, Hicksian IC approach has more diverse applicability and practical than Marshallian MVI approach.