Topper Copies

"Marshallian stability ensures Walrasian stability." Do you agree?

Mohit Aggarwal Nadbaiwalla, AIR 281, 2025

Qd = 100-P , P = 100-Qd Qs = 200-P , P = 200/5 - Qs/5

Walrasian stability is based on price adjustment of through excess demand and excess supply by entry or exit of firms. It is general equilibrium model.

Marshallian however is ceteris paribus quantity adjustment model based on marginal willingness to pay (WTP) and willingness to sell (WTS)

[two price-quantity diagrams, fig 1 for Walras and fig 2 for Marshall, each with demand and supply curves crossing at the initial equilibrium]

Initial equilibrium in both fig 1 and fig 2 exists at P0 (Price) and quantity q0

Walrasian stability → Any disturbance, suppose at Price P1 (from P0), leads to excess demand (AB), that will induce firms to raise Price further and will take equilibrium away from 'unique point' P0, q0. Similarly in case of Price fall (P2), lead to Perpetual walrasian disequilibrium (fig-1)

Marshallian stability – fig-2 Any disturbance from initial equilibrium to quantity q1 (q1<q0), will show higher WTP than LTS. This will induce firms to raise quantity. downward movement on both supply and demand curve will re-stabilise the equilibrium position Similarly, if disturbance leads to q2 (q2>q0), there will be MWTS > WTP, this will reduce quantity & stabilise equilibrium.

In this case, stability exists in marshallian model & instability in walrasian