Concentration of a market and competitive behaviour. (The booklet prints no question; this is what the answer was plainly written to: whether market concentration always means monopolistic behaviour.)
Mohit Aggarwal Nadbaiwalla, AIR 281, 2025
When 'outcome of market' is dependent on few firms only, then market is said to be concentrated, measures through degree of concentration or Herfindahl Index.
Concentration generally lead to oligopolistic/ monopoly behaviour, but in certain conditions, it can also lead to Competitive behaviour :
Case-1 : Existence of [?] duopoly with simultaneous price setting: Bertrand model — of homogeneous product, with unlimited capacity and only 2 producers.
In such case, market will produce competitive output at P = MC, even though there exist possibility of higher economic profit.
The reason is collusion is not possible as credible threat is lacking and possibility of punishment on the part of competitors is not there.
So Backward induction suggest non-collusion, with each firm producing competitive output at competitive Price even though degree of concentration is very high.
Case-II → Presence of contestable markets - when sunk cost is zero - High entry and exist of firm is possible - In such situation, a monopolist could not charge higher than P=mc=mR, if she/he does by virtue of market Concentration, it will [?] other firms to enter and increase supply
Therefore, monopolist will produce at competitive equilibrium.
Case-III Government regulations, (essentials/utility) - Government mandates Average Cost pricing in natural monopoly
[a graph of price against quantity with a downward-sloping AC curve above a flatter MC curve, and a horizontal line from Pc meeting AC with a vertical drop to Qc]
Therefore, Concentration does not guarantee Monopolistic high degree of monopoly.