Do you agree with the statement that a monopolist does not have a supply curve? Explain your answer.
Tarun Pawar, AIR 311, 2025
Supply curve shows quantity reactions of firms for various given prices.
It traces out a unique price-output relation when firm is a price taker and exercise no control over prices.
However, a monopolist exercise complete control over prices. Unlike perfect competition, a monopolist does not equate price with marginal cost and thus portion of MC curve above Total avg. variable cost curve does not indicate its supply curve.
Instead, a monopolist equates MR and MC and since MR lies below AR curve, shifts in demand causing changes in price can lead to different prices for same quantity or same price for different quantities.
[a graph of price/cost against quantity with two downward-sloping demand curves D1 and D2 and dashed marginal revenue curves MR1 and MR2, prices P1 and P2 marked, showing different prices for the same quantity Q]
- Shift in demand leading to different prices for same quantity.
[a graph of price against quantity with AR1, AR2, MR1, MR2 from a common intercept, a rising MC and a horizontal line at price P, MR1 and MR2 meeting MC at Q1 and Q2, showing different quantities at the same price]
- Change in demand leading to different quantities at same price.
Thus, it can be seen that no unique price-output relation exits in case of monopoly and thus Supply curve does not exist.