Why do changes in government purchases of goods services have a larger effect on equilibrium income level that equal-sized changes in government transfer payments?
Tarun Pawar, AIR 311, 2025
Equal size changes in govt. purchase of goods & services (G) have larger effect on eq. income than equal-sized changes in govt. transfer payments i.e. R̄.
Mathematically,
Y = C̄ + cY_d + I + G + NX
└> closed economy = 0
Y_d = Y – tY + R̄
Y = C̄ + c(Y–tY+R̄) + I + G
Y[1–c+ct] = C̄ + cR̄ + I + G
Change in output = [multiplier X ΔĀ]
↓
autonomous expenditure
ΔY = ( c / (1–c+ct) ) ΔR̄
In case of govt. expenditure
ΔY = ( 1 / (1–c+ct) ) ΔG
since value of marginal propensity to consume is < 1 i.e. c < 1
c/(1-c+ct) < 1/(1-c+ct)
ΔY/ΔR̄ < ΔY/ΔG
Value of govt. expenditure multiplier is higher than value of transfer payment multiplier because in transfer payment case, only a proportion 'c' (MPC) is spent on consumption and '1-c' (MPS) is saved.
But in case of govt expenditure, entire amount is spent which leads to higher 'ripple effects' in the economy.