Topper Copies

Explain the concept of crowding cut, Also explain the extreme cases with suitable diagrams: (i) Full crowding out (ii) No crowding out

Tarun Pawar, AIR 311, 2025

Crowding out phenomenon says that an increase in government borrowings from the market increases interest rate in the economy and thus leads to fall in private investment.

Partial crowding out

[an IS-LM graph with upward-sloping LM, IS(G₀) shifting right to IS(G₁), equilibria E₀ and E₁, Y₀ Y₁ Y₂ and i₀ i₁ marked, and a horizontal arrow from E₀ labelled 1/(1-c) ΔG₁]

- An increase in govt. expenditure increases income temporarily to Y₂. - But as Y increases, Md also increases (transaction md) thus interest rate increases to reduce speculative md for money market equilibrium. This increase in interest rate reduces the impact of fiscal expansion and output rises by lesser amount than it would have if interest rate would not have risen.

Size of crowding out = Y₂ - Y₁

(i) Full crowding out

(a) Classical Case -> vertical LM

interest elasticity of M^d = 0

[an IS-LM graph with a vertical LM line and IS(G0) shifting to IS'(G1), raising the interest rate from i0 to i1]

- In such case, fiscal policy is completely ineffective

(b) case of full employment

[an AD-AS graph with upward-sloping AS, vertical line at Y_F, and AD shifting from P0 to P1, beside an IS-LM graph with LM(M0/P1) and LM(M0/P0) and IS, IS' with Y_F marked]

In case of full employment, crowding out occurs from a different channel. Fiscal expansion at Y_F lead to increased prices, which shift LM curve back to original position as real money supply reduces.

(ii) No crowding out

(a) Liquidity Trap case (Keynesian)

[an IS-LM graph with a horizontal LM line at i0 and IS(G0) shifting to IS(G1), Y0 and Y1 marked]

- when interest elasticity of md → ∞, LM curve is horizontal & we have zero crowding-out as interest rate do not rise.

(b) Policy mix case

[an IS-LM graph with LM and LM' and IS curves, Y and Y' marked]

- when increase in govt. expenditure is combined with monetary expansion, increase in interest rate can be avoided and thus no crowding out.

Thus, it can be said that extent of crowding out is positively related with slope of LM curve. Or in other words, effectiveness of fiscal policy is inversely related to slope of LM.