Compare and contrast the classical dichotomy and monetary neutrality with Keynesian views on the effectiveness of monetary policy in influencing real economic activity.
Tarun Pawar, AIR 311, 2025
Classical dichotomy says that in Classical theory, real and nominal variables are determined by two different set of factors. Real factors like population, technology and capital stock determines real variables like output and employment. Real interest rates are determined by factors of productivity and thrift, i.e. real savings, real investment and real govt. budget deficit. However, nominal factors like money only affects nominal variables like nominal wage, price, nominal income, etc.
Thus, the conclusion that money is neutral in its effect on real variables.
Therefore, according to classical view, money cannot affect real variables and any attempt to increase real output by expansionary monetary policy would only lead to increase in price level as shown in figure
[a graph of price against real output with a vertical AS at Y_F and two downward-sloping curves AD(M,V) and AD(M₀V), P₀ and P₁ marked]
Reasons for ineffective role of money :- 1. Complete stabilizing role of interest rate 2. Complete information assumption 3. Complete wage-price flexibility.
⇓
These ensure that economy stays at full employment level.
Keynesian View
According to early Keynesians, money does affect real variables, however the impact is relatively lesser when compared to fiscal policy.
This is because, according to early Keynesians, LM curve was relatively flatter because of liquidity trap condition.
[an IS-LM graph with IS, LM and a lower parallel LM1 with an arrow showing the shift, i0 i1 and Y0 Y1 marked]
But later Keynesians, agree that money does affect real variables.
In contrast to Classical view of vertical LM curve, early Keynesians maintained that LM curve is flatter.
Later on, Monetarists led by Milton Friedman, emphasized that money does affect real variables in short run while money is neutral in its effect on real variables in long run.