Show the consumer surplus, profit and deadweight loss of a monopoly firm when (i) price discrimination is not allowed, and (ii) the firm practices first-degree price discrimination.
Tarun Pawar, AIR 311, 2025
Monopoly is a form of market where there is a single seller selling (or producing) a goods that have no close substitutes.
(i) when price discrimination not allowed
[a monopoly graph of price/cost against quantity with downward-sloping AR from H, steeper MR, rising MC and U-shaped AC, with Pm, Pc, points A, B, C, D, E, F, G and quantities N and m marked]
A monopolist maximizes profit by using mR = mC condition :- Price = Pm ; Output = ON
In perfect competition :- Price = Pc (where P= mc) output Qty = OM
Comparing these , we have :-
consumer surplus = AHP_m
Profits = AEFP_m
Deadweight loss = ABC
⇊
This indicates social cost of monopoly caused by misallocation of resources as P = MC condition is not used in monopoly for profit maximization
(ii) First degree price discrimination
[a graph of price against quantity with a straight downward-sloping demand line DD and the area under it filled with stepped rectangles, an arrow from it to 'Σ MR = TR']
- DD - demand curve - Σ MR = TR
when a seller is able to sell each separate unit of output to consumers at different prices, it is called first degree price discrimination.
- It causes 'maximum possible exploitation' of consumers as monopolist uses separate bargain with each consumer and thus no consumer surplus is left.
Eg. E- commerce websites using customer history to charge different prices from different consumers.
Here, AR and MR curve are same and assuming zero cost, we have:-
Consumer surplus = 0
Profits = entire shaded area under demand curve
Deadweight loss = 0
↓
because, Price = MR = MC = 0