Topper Copies

Explain how Keynesian speculative demand for money is restated in regressive expectation model. Point out its limitations.

Polavarapu Dhwanish, AIR 108, 2025

According to Keynesian speculative demand for money, households keep money or bonds depending on the value of interest rate.

If households speculate that interest rates will rise in the future then, they prefer to keep cash and vice versa.

This speculative demand for money is restated in regressive expectation model.

According to regressive expectations model, price of rate of return on (r) bond is a ratio of bond yield and (Y) its price (P_b)

r = Y/P_b

Now in terms, of expected gains

g = (P_b^e − P_b) / P_b , where g is gains due to rise in price of bonds expected in future .

g = (1/r^e − 1/r) / (1/r)

or g = r/r^e − 1 , Total capital gain is [r + r/r^e − 1] rate

Now, to find critical interest rate below which households would prefer to keep only cash, we take gains from bonds to be zero.

0 = r/r_e − 1 + r . [r_c = critical rate of interest]

0 = r/r_e − 1 + r

r_c = r/r_e1 − 1 r_c = r_e / (1+r_e)

or [r_c = r_e / (1+r_e)]

[a vertical axis of interest rate divided by a horizontal line at r_c: above it "only bond" (r > r_c), below it "only cash"]

Since, below critical rate of interest rate (r_c), households prefer & keep only cash and above it only bonds, therefore we can say that Keynesian speculative demand is related in regressive expectation model, as regressive expectations lead to same outcome as speculative demand for money with respect to households keeping only cash or only bonds

However, the limitation of this model is that in reality, households do not allocate their assets in the form of only cash or only bond. This prefer to build a portfolio of both cash and bonds as is explained in Tobin's model depending on several factors such as interest rates, cost of going to bank, income of household etc.