Topper Copies

(a) What is a Customs' Union? Discuss the effects of a Customs' Union formation under partial equilibrium conditions.

Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024

[Customs Union] is a form of economic integration between nations, where mutual tariff-barriers are removed and uniform trade policy is adopted towards the non-members. eg European Union, Mercosur.

Effects of a Customs Union depend on whether it is trade creating, or trade diverting in nature.

Assumptions 1. Three countries - A, B, C 2. A imports good - X from B & C 3. A is a small nation

Trade Creating Custom Union - Let the cost of producing x in A, B, C is 5, 2 and 1 respectively - A imposes tariff of 2 on B & C and thus imports goods from C at 3 /unit

Country- A

[a supply and demand graph for Country-A with P on the vertical axis and Q on the horizontal axis, upward-sloping S and downward-sloping demand, horizontal price lines at 3 and 1, points A and B on the price-3 line and C and D on the price-1 line, the region between divided into areas a, b, c and d; caption: Fig: Effect of tariff removal]

A + C form a custom union. This leads to removal of tariff of 2/unit on C and thus, import price of X in A falls to 1 per unit.

Effect of fall in price to 1/unit:- 1. customer's welfare rises by area (a+b+c+d). Producer surplus falls by area (a). Tariff revenue lost to govt is area (C). Thus there is net gain (b+d) 2. Welfare of members rises due to rise in trade volume from AB to CD 3. Greater specialisation of production as per comparative advantage raises overall welfare for world 4. Welfare of non-members also rises as rise in income of members spills-over to them as higher import demands

Thus, trade creating custom union raises welfare .

Trade Directing Custom Union

[a Country-A demand and supply graph with P on the vertical axis and Q on the horizontal axis, downward-sloping demand and upward-sloping supply, horizontal price lines at 1, 2 and 3, areas a, b, c, d and e marked; caption: Fig: Effect of tariff-removal on B]

->Let A & B form a custom union. So 2/unit tariff on B is removed & now it can export good -X at price of 2 , that is cheaper than after tariff price of 3 from country C. - Thus, internal price in country-A falls to 2/unit . This raises trade volume -> Trade creation effect - But trade is directed away from more productive country C to less productive B → Trade diversion effect - The net welfare effect is as under:- 1. Within A : Consumer surplus rises by area (a+b+c+d), producer surplus falls by area (a) & tariff revenue lost is area (c+e). Thus net effect is b+d-e. Whether it is true or -ve is unknown 2. Wrong pattern of specialisation leads to fall in world's welfare 3. Non-member's welfare falls due to diversion of trade away from them

Thus, the net effect of trade-diverting custom union is uncertain - it depends on which of the two effects - trade creation and trade diversion is dominating.