Topper Copies

(c) 'A nation loses control over money supply under fixed exchange rate regime with perfect capital mobility (at constant prices), thus making monetary policy completely ineffective in changing output. However fiscal policy is fully effective in this case'. Do you agree? Explain.

Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024

Mundel flemming model shows that monetary policy is ineffective in fixed exchange rate regime and fiscal policy is fully effective.

Assumptions 1. Fixed exchange rate 2. Perfect capital mobility 3. constant prices, until full employment

Monetary Policy Ineffectiveness

[an IS-LM-BP graph with i on the vertical axis and Y on the horizontal axis, a horizontal BP line at i_f, a downward-sloping IS₁, upward-sloping LM₁(M₁) and LM₂(M₂) with an arrow showing the shift, point 1 where IS₁, LM₁ and BP meet and point 2 where IS₁ and LM₂ meet, below BP]

- when money supply is raised from M₁ to M₂, LM shifts right, new equilibrium is at point 2 - But at point-2, domestic interest is below foreign interest. This leads to capital outflow and puts pressure on domestic currency to depreciate - To avoid depreciation, central bank has to buy domestic currency and sell forex. This shifts LM back to LM, due to fall in money supply - Thus, economy returns to point 1 and output is unchanged. So monetary policy is ineffective - Central bank tried to raise money supply, but had to reduce it again to avoid capital outflow & depreciation. Hence, the bank has no control over money supply. This is called IMPOSSIBLE TRINITY of perfect capital mobility, fixed exchange rate and independent monetary policy

Fiscal policy - fully effective - when govt. spending is raised from G1 to G2, IS shifts right to IS2. New equilibrium is at point 2

[an IS-LM-BP graph with i on the vertical axis and Y on the horizontal axis, a horizontal BP line at i_f, two IS lines with IS2 labelled (G↑), LM1 (M1) and LM2 (M2), intersection points 1, 2, 3 and 4, Y1 and Y2 marked on the Y axis with dashed verticals]

- At point 2, domestic interest is greater than foreign interest. This causes capital inflows & pressure of appreciation on currency - To avert appreciation, central bank sells domestic currency and buys foreign exchange. This raises money supply and shifts LM rightward to LM2 - New equilibrium is at point 3

Here, output has raised from Y1 to Y2. Thus, fiscal policy is fully effective under fixed exchange rate regime.