2. (a) Show that, following a monetary expansion, exchange rate, in the short- run, overshoots its new medium run equilibrium value. Explain. Show that the long-run behavior of nominal exchange rate is an extension of neutrality of money to open economy?
Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024
[Exchange Rate overshooting] refers to a situation when monetary expansion causes exchange rate to overshoot its equilibrium value in the short run.
Mundell - Fleming model can be used to explain this phenomenon.
Assumptions 1. Perfect capital mobility 2. Full employment at Yf 3. Flexible Exchange Rate system
Impact of monetary expansion
[a graph with i on the vertical axis and Y on the horizontal axis, a horizontal line at i_f, LM1 (M1) and LM2 (M2), IS1 (NX1) and IS2 (NX2), intersection points 1, 2 and 3 with arrows showing the shifts, Y_f and Y1 marked on the Y axis]
When money supply is raised from M1 to M2, LM shifts right. At new equilibrium at 2, i < if, so capital flows out of economy leading to depreciation of currency. This raises net exports & IS shifts right to IS2. Thus, equilibrium is reached at pt 3, where income Y1 > Yf (full employment level)
- Since Y > Yf, there is rise in prices. This reduces nominal money supply and also makes domestic good expensive ; thereby reduces NX - Thus, IS & LM shift back to original levels and equilibrium is restored at point 1
Exchange Rate overshooting Time paths of key variables are as under:-
[a box of four time-path graphs against t, each with a dotted vertical at t0: M flat at M1 then jumping to M2; i flat at i1, dipping sharply to i2 at t0 then recovering to i1; P flat at P1 then rising gradually to P2; E flat at E1, jumping to E3 at t0 then declining gradually toward a dashed E2]
Money supply jumps immediately. Interest rate is determined by money market & thus reduces immediately. Exchange rate is determined in financial market & thus rises quickly. But price is set in commodity market and thus takes time to rise.
Long run behaviour of exchange rate - In long run, exchange rate falls from E3 to E2. and price rises from P1 to P2 - We see that nominal variables - money supply & price rise, but real variables - real money supply & real exchange rate are constant i.e. % Δ in M = % Δ in P = % Δ in E => M/P and E/P are constant (real money) (real exchange rate)
Thus, money is neutral as it does not affect real variables. This is monetary neutrality extension to open economy