Topper Copies

(c) Distinguish between 'Internal Rate of Return' (IRR) and 'Net Present Value' (NPV)' criteria of evaluating public investment projects. What is the role of shadow prices in this context?

Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024

Public investment project evaluation involves cost-benefit analysis of available projects to select the most efficient one.

IRR and NPV are two different criteria for project evaluation.

Internal Rate of Return (IRR) criteria - IRR (r) is the rate of interest at which the net present value of a project becomes zero - Net Present Value (NPV) is the discounted value of expected streams of cost & benefit of a project - For eg, if a project has cost of C₀ at onset & yields benefit streams of B₁, B₂, B₃ ... in subsequent periods, then NPV of this project is:-

NPV = -C₀ + B₁/(1+r) + B₂/(1+r)² + ... + Bₙ/(1+r)ⁿ

The value of r at which NPV = 0 is IRR

Criteria for selecting project :-

[a boxed graph with NPV on the vertical axis and rate on the horizontal axis, a straight line falling from the upper left and crossing the horizontal axis at a circled point IRR, with an arrow to a circled NPV=0]

- If IRR > actual interest rate → select the project - If IRR < actual interest rate → reject the project - If IRR = 0 → indifferent

NPV Criteria (Net Present value) - NPV of a project is calculated as above - Selection criteria :- If NPV > 0 then benefits > cost, so project is selected. If NPV < 0, then benefits < cost, so project is rejected

Role of shadow prices in this context - When actual costs of inputs is not available, shadow prices are used to analyse cost & benefits - shadow prices are true-value of an input that represent its actual cost