"An economist should know how to distinguish between a policy change which is an improvement and one which makes things worse." In the light of the above statement, outline some important criteria for welfare judgment.
Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024
Welfare economics deals with evaluating different policies from the perspective of welfare of society : Different criteria for welfare judgement
Pareto Criteria As per pareto, an economic change is optimal if it makes someone better off without making others worseoff . It has three conditions :-
1. Production Optimality :- Production of a good can't be raised without lowering production of other.
[an Edgeworth box with corners K, Oy, Ox and L and a diagonal contract line with isoquants of x and y tangent to it]
It happens along the contract curve marked by tangency of Iso-quant curves of x & y. 2. Consumption Optimality :- Consumption of one agent can't rise without reducing consumption of other.
[an Edgeworth box with corners O_A and O_B and axes X and Y, with a contract curve through the tangency points]
Consumption contract curve shows consumption optimality 3. Optimal product mix : when social indifference curve is tangent to PPF, optimal product mix is obtained at x*, y*.
[a graph with a concave PPF and a convex SIC tangent to it, y* on the Y axis and x* on the X axis]
Hicks-Kaldor criteria Pareto criteria suffered from a limitation - it could not judge policies that make someone better off and others worse off. Kaldor - Hicks criteria gives a solution to such cases by postulating that a policy change is beneficial if the gainers can compensate the loser & still be better off.
Scitovsky Criteria Kaldor-Hicks criteria fails when the Utility possibility frontiers intersect. Scitovsky solved this paradox by postulating a reversal test - the gainers must-be able to compensate the loser and be better off, but the loser must not be able to compensate the gainer & be better off.
However, even Scitovsky's criteria doesn't determine optimal policy change if two UPFs intersect.