A monopolist sells a good in two markets. Demand in the two markets is given as Q1 = 120 – P1 and Q2 = 20 – P2. The marginal cost of the monopolist is given as 10 and the fixed cost is zero. (i) Computer the profit maximising prices and quantities of the monopolist when he practices third degree price discrimination. (ii) Compute the profit maximising price and quantity of the monopolist when he charges a uniform price in both the markets.
Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024
Given :- - Demand in market - 1 : Q1 = 120 - P1 - Demand in market - 2 : Q2 = 20 - P2 - Marginal Cost : c = 10 - Fixed cost : FC = 0
(i) Third degree price discrimination In this case, monopolist charges a different price in both markets, such that marginal revenue in both markets equals marginal cost, i.e. MR1 = MR2 = MC
[three side-by-side graphs: market 1 with AR1, market 2 with AR2, and Aggregate with AR, MR and a rising MC, P1 and P2 marked; Fig: Price Discrimination]
finding MR1 TR1 = P1 . Q1 = (120 - Q1) Q1 = 120Q1 - Q1² ∴ MR1 = dTR1/dQ1 = 120 - 2Q1
finding MR2 TR2 = P2·Q2 = (20-Q2) Q2 = 20Q2 - Q2² ∴ MR2 = dTR2/dQ2 = 20 - 2Q2
Now, MR1 = MR2 = MC = 10
so, MR1 = 10 ⇒ 120 - 2Q1 = 10 ⇒ 2Q1 = 110 ⇒ Q1 = 55 ∴ P1 = 120 - Q1 = 65
MR2 = 10 ⇒ 20 - 2Q2 = 10 ⇒ 2Q2 = 10 ⇒ Q2 = 5 P2 = 20 - Q2 = 15 .
Thus, monopolist sells 55 units in market -1 at price 65 and 5 units in market 2 at price 15 .
(ii) uniform price in both the markets In this case, monopolist will equate aggregate marginal revenue (derived from aggregate market-demand) to marginal cost ie AMR = MC
Finding AMR :-
Aggregate Demand of Market 1 & 2 :- Q = Q1 + Q2 Q = 120 - P + 20 - P => Q = 140 - 2P
TR = P.Q = (70 - Q/2) . Q = 70Q - Q²/2
MR = dTR/dQ = 70 - 1/2 . 2Q = 70 - Q
Now, MR = MC => 70 - Q = 10 => Q* = 60 P* = 70 - 30 = 40
The monopolist will sell 60 units at price ₹40 in both markets combined.