Explain the circumstances under which monetary and fiscal policy measures may be ineffective in stimulating economic growth or managing economic downturns. Discuss the potential limitations and challenges faced by policymakers in implementing these policies.
Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024
Monetary policy used uses changes in ↑ money supply to affect macro variables like output, price, employment. Fiscal policy is a tool that employs government income and expenditure policy affect macro variables.
Circumstances when monetary policy can be ineffective :- 1. Liquidity Trap → In this case LM curve is horizontal due to infinite speculative money demand. It happens at very low interest rate, when money supply changes can't lower interests any more and thus monetary policy is ineffective.
[an IS-LM graph with a horizontal stretch of LM that then rises, labelled LM1 and LM2, and a dotted line down to y*] 2. Open Economy with fixed exchange rate & perfect capital mobility → Increase in money supply shifts LM1 to LM2.
[an IS curve with LM1 and LM2 shifting and a horizontal BP line]
But as interest falls bellow international interest, threat of capital outflow & depreciation forces central bank to reduce money supply. LM2 shifts back to LM1 & policy is ineffective. 3. vertical IS curve → This happens during low business expectations or downturns.
[an IS-LM graph with a vertical IS line and parallel LM1 and LM2]
Interest elasticity of investment is zero. so change in interest doesn't affect investment & policy is ineffective.
Circumstances when fiscal policy is ineffective :- 1. vertical LM curve → It is the classical case, when money demand is not a function of interest-
[an IS-LM graph with a vertical LM and IS1 and IS2 to its right]
so rise in govt. spending from G1 to G2 shifts IS1 to IS2. But output doesn't rise and policy is ineffective. 2. Flexible exchange rate & perfect capital mobility →
[an IS-LM graph with a horizontal BP line, IS1 (G1) and IS2 (G2), arrows showing a shift right and back]
Govt spending rise (from G1 to G2) shifts IS1 to IS2. But higher interest causes capital inflows & appreciation that reduces net exports and IS2 shifts back to IS1. Output is unchanged & policy ineffective. 3. Flexible price & full employment
[an AD-AS graph with a vertical full-employment line, and an IS-LM graph with LM1 (P1), LM2 (P2), IS1 (G1), IS2 (G2) and a dashed line down to Yf]
Rise in G shifts IS1 to IS2, but due to full employment, price rises and real money supply falls from P1 to P2. This shifts LM1 to LM2 and output is unchanged, thus policy ineffective.
Thus, the policymakers face challenges in using fiscal and monetary policy for affecting output