Analyze the policy implications of the classical equilibrium model in macroeconomics. Discuss how the model's assumptions of flexible prices, full employment, and self-adjusting markets shape the recommendations for monetary and fiscal policy.
Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024
Classical macroeconomic model is based on Smith's laisses faire concept, where invisible hand of the market leads to full employment output.
Assumptions of the model 1. Price and wage flexibility 2. Perfect information with agents 3. No state intervention.
Policy implications The classical model has two lines of defence that always lead to full employment :-
1. stabilising role of interest rate that ensures changes in components of AD do not effect AD. 2. supply - determined output that means changes in AD do not affect output.
[three linked graphs: output against labour, price against output with a vertical AS at Y1 and a downward AD, and a labour market with LS and Ld meeting at w* and L*; Fig: classical equilibrium]
In above diagram, equilibrium in labour market between labour demand and labour supply leads to employment of L* labour units. This produces output of Y1. AS curve is vertical at Y1. So AD shifts can't effect output.
Monetary Policy [three linked graphs: production function, price against output with AD1 and AD2 cutting a vertical AS at P1 and P2, and a labour market with Ls1, Ls2, Ld1, Ld2 and wages W1, W2; Fig: Effect of rise in money supply]
Rise in money supply raises AD, since money is the only factor affecting AD. AD shifts from AD1 to AD2, causing price rise from P1 to P2. But this raises labour demand from Ld1 to Ld2 and lowers labour supply from Ls1 to Ls2. In end, wage rise equals price rise, real wage remaining same, employment & output unchanged.
Thus, monetary policy is ineffective.
Fiscal Policy Case A: change in government expenditure or lump sum tax :-
Due to stabilising role of interest rate, AD doesn't shift & thus, output and price is unaffected.
Thus, fiscal policy is ineffective.
Case B: change in proportional tax.
[three linked graphs: production function Y = f(L) with Y1 and Y2, price against output with AS1 and AS2 and a downward AD, and a labour market with Ld and two supply curves Ls1(t1) and Ls2(t2), (t2 < t1)]
Reduction in proportional tax to t2 raises incentive of workers to work & so, they supply greater labour force. LS shifts from L1^S to L2^S → labour employed rises to L2 & output rises to Y2. This shifts AS1 to AS2 and thus output rises & price falls -
This is the only case where fiscal policy is effective.
Thus, classicals prescribe no monetary or fiscal policy due to their ineffectiveness, except in one case of proportional income tax.