Compare and Contrast HDI and multi-dimensional poverty Index measuring welfare.
Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025
Human development Index was propounded by mahbool-ul-Haq in 1990 which entails that development includes widening choices for individual and improving dignified life via higher standard of living a better health and education. It was later adopted by UNDP and has been published annually as part of Human Development Report. India's rank has been marginally improving under Human development
HDI : considers 3 parameters:- 1. Standard of living (per capita income in PPP terms) 2. Health (using life expectancy parameter) 3. Education (using expected years of schooling and mean years)
value computed as Geometric mean of all 3 indices ( Index = Actual-Min / Max-Min )
However, it suffers from various issues - 1. No consideration of income distribution 2. Skewed towards developed economies and too much focused on education which in turn derives income (High education -> High Income - overvalued HDI) 3. Doesn't measure actual deprivations
Multidimensional Poverty Index
It was brought by Oxford and wellbeing/life to measure poverty beyond economic deprivation. It includes - i) Sanitation ii) Access to resources iii) Power and electricity iv) Financial Inclusion v) Education and Health
MDPI is a overall better indicator to gauge human development as it is holistic in nature India has shown significant development as 271 million out of poverty since last 28 years