Topper Copies

Using suitable diagrams to illustrate the ineffectiveness of monetary policy and the effectiveness of fiscal policy under a fixed exchange rate regime with perfect capital mobility.

Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025

Mundell-fleming model is an extension of Keynesian IS-LM model in open macroeconomy which studies impact of fiscal policy and monetary policy.

Assumptions — 1. Perfect capital mobility 2. Existing IS-LM framework 3. Fixed exchange rate

FIXED Exchange Rate Entails Central Bank pegs the exchange rate to a fixed value which means Balance of payments Graph remains vertical and cannot move

IMPACT OF MONETARY POLICY

As per Impossible Trinity in case of fixed exchange rate, Central Bank loses autonomy over monetary policy as shown in Fig 1

[Fig 1: an IS-LM graph with interest rates against output, LM(M₀) shifting to LM(M₁), a downward-sloping IS and a horizontal BOP = 0 line at i = i_f]

As central bank increases monetary supply from M₀ to M₁, LM moves out (Mˢ = Mᵈ = KY − hi)

a) As a result, Interest rates fall due to monetary policy transmission → [capital outflows]

b) This puts pressure on Exchange Rate to depreciate due to capital outflow

c) In order to keep exchange rate fixed, central bank must reduce supply of domestic currency

Hence, Monetary policy Remains ineffective (Impossible Trilemma)

Impact of Fiscal Policy This entails increasing government spending to boost aggregate demand and IS curve shifts out

[an IS-LM graph with BP at i = i_f, LM(M0) shifting to LM(M1), IS0 (G0) shifting to IS1 (G1), Y0 and Y1 marked, labelled Fig: No crowding out]

As IS shifts due to higher Government spending, 1. Interest rate rises (due to crowding out lendency) 2. This leads to capital Inflows and pressure on currency to appreciate 3. To keep exchange rate fixed, Central Bank must increase domestic currency supply (M0 to M1) Hence - output and employment increases from Y0 to Y1 due to Fiscal Policy.

Mundel Fleming model Acts as effective tool to study the effectiveness of government policies in Open Economy