“Trade benefits the factor that is specific to the export sector of each country but hurts the factor specific to the import- competing sectors, with ambiguous effects on mobile factors” Explain.
Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025
Specific factors Model tries to assess the impact of trade on various factors of production which could be mobile to one sector (labor) or Immobile to another sector (land and capital)
Assumptions 1. 2 goods - Food - cloth 2. 3 Factors - land (specific to food) - labor (mobile) - capital (specific to cloth) 3. Free Trade with comparative advantage (using HO model)
Model As per Specific factors model, impact of trade is Ambiguous on Mobile factors, whereas impact the specific factors depending on they belong to export sector or Import sector
[fig: VMP move due to increase in Relative Prices, a graph with VMP_L and VMP_K on the two vertical axes against labor]
As Pc/Pf increases when nation specialises in cloth production, assuming cloth is labor intensive and food is capital intensive (a) Real wage rate for labor in cloth sector (Import) falls but real wage rate for labor in food sector (export) rises. This leaves overall Impact as ambiguous (b) Due to increased marginal productivity of capital in export sector, (more of Capital), labor available for same amount of Capital, real return to Capital sector rises (Specific to Export sector) (c) Similarly, due to fall in marginal productivity of land . real return to land ie factor specific to Import sector falls
[two graphs of MPL against labor, Cloth: rise in real return to capital, Food: fall in real return to land]
overall
| Type | | Real Return | |---|---|---| | labor | Mobile | Ambiguous | | Capital | Specific (Export) | Rises | | land | Specific (Import) | Falls |
Hence, This is in contrast to Ho Model and Factor Price equalisation theorem which states that all abundant factors gains whereas all scarce factors loses
Hence it is rightly said that - 1. Trade Benefits factor specific to export sector and hurts factors specific to import - Reason why capital owners favor trade in USA but land owners disfavor trade in USA 2. However, overall Gains from trade due to → Increase in world output (Ricado) → Greater Specialisation (HO model) → Economies of scale → Market access
limitations of specific factors model 1. Difficult to prove empirically 2. Ignores Intra Industry trade 3. Considers only 3 factors of production 4. Ignores Transport costs