What is the difference between horizontal equity and vertical equity while considering ability to pay? How should the problem be resolved? Illustrate graphically.
Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025
The Canons of Taxation by Adam Smith suggest Principle of Equity for designing Taxation Policies. It has been incorporated under Ability to pay Principle which means Individuals pay tax based on their Capacity to pay
Forex If Income has been taken as criteria for capability then, persons with same Income should pay equal taxes -> Horizontal Equity
Similarly, person with higher Income should pay higher taxes than person with lower Taxes
1. Horizontal Equity ! This can be achieved by fixing a criteria for ability. which could be either Income Tax or Expenditure Tax ( Consumption tax)
| Income Tax | Consumption Tax | |---|---| | 1) Discourages savings | 1) Encourages savings | | 2) Administrative issues (Against canon of convenience) | 2) Ease to administer | | 3) Easy to evade | 3) Not easy to evade | | 4) Follow canon of equity | 4) Against canon of Equity as low income might consume more | | 5) Acts as automatic stabiliser | |
2. vertical Equity : It entails that given marginal utility of income as constant, equal sacrifice should be done by persons whether in terms of - a) Absolute sacrifice b) Proportional sacrifice c) Marginal sacrifice
let consider 2 persons with high income and low income with given marginal utility ↘ Income (mum) Then, show graphically.
[two graphs of marginal utility against tax / income for the two persons, with points Q, D, A, C, P, F, B and their primed counterparts]
In case of Equal sacrifice,
B' C' A' Q' = BC AQ
In case of proportional sacrifice,
B'P'Q'A' / Total utility = BPQA / Total utility
In case of equimarginal sacrifice,
DF = D'F'
Hence, proportional and equimarginal sacrifices meet the progressive taxation & Vertical equity and Horizontal equity could be achieved via Token Income tax rates as proposed under Income Tax Act