Topper Copies

What is the difference between Fisher's theory and Cambridge cash balance approach to quantity theory of money? What is the criticism of each? Which one is more relevant in present context? Justify.

Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025

Fisher Theory and Cambridge cash Balance approach are [classical approaches] to Quantity Theory of Money. Both have few similarities like Monetary neutrality, full employment levels and [Inflation] as consequence of Monetary Policies However, they hold various differences

FISHER

1. Considers Money as medium of Exchange 2. Any increase in Money leads to proportionate and equal increase in Money supply 3. Accounting approach, hence more mechanistic in nature 4. Equation of Exchange Involves - MV̄ = PȲ V= velocity of money (Determined by Institutional factors) Ȳ = constant (classical Supply determined)

[a graph with Money on the vertical axis and Prices on the horizontal axis, a straight line from the origin labelled MV̄=PȲ at 45°, boxed Fisher]

CRITICISM 1. Ignores role of interest rates in money demand 2. Too mechanistic and doesnot explain Price mechanism 3. Criticised by Keynes, Tobin & Baumol as money is an asset

CAMBRIDGE

1. Considers Money as medium of exchange and Store of value 2. Any increase in impacts nominal Income in form of proportion 3. Behavioral approach and actual Theory of money demand 4. Equation of money demand - Mᵈ = KPY K is the proportion of nominal Income which is demanded in form of money K= constant (determined by Institutional factors)

[a graph with Mᵈ (Money) on the vertical axis and Nominal Income [PY] on the horizontal axis, a straight line from the origin labelled Mᵈ = KPY, slope K]

CRITICISM 1. Ignores role of speculative demand for money , only considers transactional demand 2. Ignores interest rate roles 3. Money Impacts output and employment too ( eg Keynes, GFC)

MORE RELEVANT

(1) Cambridge cash Balance seems to be more relevant due to below reasons - i) Studies behavioral aspect of money demand ii) Explains why money increase leads to price increase as " Too much money chasing too few goods" iii) Taken used as foundational tool by monetarists like Milton Friedman iv) Broader framework for Theory of money demand

Hence, despite limitations Fisher and Cambridge approach have been widely accepted across all schools of thought in macro economics