Explain Chamberlin model of monopolistic competition with free entry and price competition. Use diagram to Explain.
Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025
Monopolistic Competition involves large number of small firms producing differentiated products ( eg. Colgate, Pepsodyne) with free entry and exit of firms. Chamberlin model of monopolistic competition aims to find short run and long run equilibrium by defining concept of 'Group' over industry
Assumptions — 1. Product differentiation 2. Entry and exit allowed 3. Small number of large firms 4. Price and non price competition
Chamberlin Heroic Assumptions to resolve the difficulty of defining Industry :
1. Uniformity : All firms have identical costs and face same demand curve 2. Asymmetry : Any decision by one firm wont impact proportional sales due to small share & hence independent decision making
FREE ENTRY AND PRICE COMPETITION
a) Free entry means there are no barriers to entry of firms ——> Due to excess profits
b) Price competition means Planned Sales curve (perceived) as demand curve
[Fig 1: Short Run Equilibrium and Supernormal profits, a graph of prices against output with MC, AC, AR(dd) and MR and a shaded supernormal profit rectangle]
[Fig 2: Long Run Equilibrium with no profits, a graph of price against output with MC, AC, AR(dd) and D, equilibrium E where demand touches AC]
Fig 1 : As firms earn Supernormal profits in short run, hence new firms will enter the market ( Free entry allowed ) This will reduce the share of each firm hence shifting demand curve to the left
Fig 2 : In long run, there will not be any supernormal profits as equilibrium at point of Tangency
Implications — 1. Price higher than Perfect competition and output lower than Perfect competition 2. [Cassel]: Excess capacity due to economically inefficient plant and Socially Inoptimal output 3. [Chamberlin]: No excess capacity under price competition as consumers pay [?] cost for wide consumer choices, Quality Improvements and differentiated Products
Limitations — 1. concept of [Industry] has been destroyed, concept of Group renders Product differentiation futile 2. Firms do consider Behavior of rival firms and there is no independent decision making
Chamberlin Model fails to explain monopolistic competition using [Planned and Perceived sales]