State first theorem of welfare economics and Explain the conditions in which it will not hold?
Monika Srivastava, AIR 16, 2025
welfare economics aims to study impact of government policies on social welfare. First Theorem of welfare economics states that there will always be a Perfectly competitive equilibrium which would be Pareto optimal in nature
Pareto optimality entails that a policy is an improvement when it leads to betterment of individuals without making someone else worse off. It requires 3 conditions to hold true-
i) Production efficiency where allocation of resources for production of goods (say A and B) leads to pareto optimality - Hence, MRTS^A_{K,L} = MRTS^B_{K,L}
ii) Allocative efficiency where allocation of goods between 2 individuals such that it achieves pareto optimality i.e MRS_{P1} = MRS_{P2}
iii) Policy Mix where amount of goods desired by individuals equals amount of goods produced in economy i.e MRS = MRTS
Hence, according to first welfare economics there will be a perfect competition equilibrium where all 3 conditions would hold true such that
MRS_A = MRS_B = P1/P2
However, it might not hold true under certain conditions :- i) Convexity at point of tangency would violate welfare economics ii) It needs point of tangency to be concave in nature
Hence, First theorem of welfare economics might help in assessing the policy improvement criteria but with certain limitation