(a) When is it more effective to pursue a Hirschmanian strategy compared to Nurksian balanced growth model approach? Discuss after explaining the essence of both the models.
Tanvi Gupta, AIR 187, 2024
Nurkse gave the Balanced growth model which argues that the Developing & Less Developed economies are characterised by "vicious cycle of poverty" that operates on both demand (DD) & supply (SS) side
This vicious cycle must be broken down to initiate growth. This requires simultaneous investment in all the sectors of the economy s.t. lack of investment in 1 sector doesnot impede development in other. It must be balanced on both DD & SS side to enable taking advantage of complementarities through horizontal & vertical integration. Thus, he called for a need for a "balanced diet"
Hirschman gave the unbalanced growth model which argued that " Development is a chain of disequilibria that must be kept alive rather than be eliminated "
This can work by unbalancing the economy in 2 ways. 1. unbalancing via SOC The govt. can provide for SOC which reduces the cost of production & induce investment in DPA. 2. Unbalancing via DPA Increase in DPA causes shortages of SOC & puts pressure on govt to increase SOC.
[a graph of DPA (vertical) against SOC (horizontal): a straight line OX through points A, B and C, with curved paths through B', C', B'' and C'']
OX = balanced growth path
In case (1), the growth path is AB"BC"C In case (2), the growth path is AB'BC'C
Hirschman prefers unbalancing via DPA as it is self-propelling. Also, initial investment must be done in sector which has highest backward forward linkages (import enclave industries)
Hirschman strategy is more effective in developing countries because of 1. shortage of resources (constraint) for simultaneous investment. 2. economic uncertainties & risk of loss.
Both BG & UBG strategies are complementary in long run as nation eventually moves along OX path (BG) through unbalancing.