Topper Copies

(a) The Harrod-Domar growth model states that a country 'growth rate of per capita income depends on its rate of savings, whereas the Solow growth model predict that a higher saving rate is incapable of leading to sustained long-run per-capita economic growth in the absence of technical progress. Explain these assertions.

Tanvi Gupta, AIR 187, 2024

Harrod-Domar (H-D) growth model states that the growth rate of the economy depends on the capital accumulation. As long as the capital accumulation takes place, the per capital output & income will increase. This capital accumulation is a function of savings rate (s) which H-D model assumes to be constant.

Actual Growth rate (G) = s/V where V = capital - output ratio

It is based on the H-D's hypothesis & arguement that assigns dual role to Investment Investment increases the productive capacity of economy & also the income of FOP As long as the increase in productive capacity matches the income growth, nation will continue to grow.

An increase in 's' increases the growth rate as it increase investment.

Solow model on the other hand states that so increase in 's' produces only level effect. while it is only neutral Technical progress ( solow residual ) that causes long term growth of per capita output.

Explanation :

The steady state exists where investment is equal to depriciation rate (δ)

Δk = Investment - δ(k) = 0 = sf(k) - δk = 0 i.e. sf(k) = δk (because I = s. Income per capita = s.Y)

[a Solow diagram of y against k: curves sk, y=f(k), s1f(k), sf(k), equilibrium E with steady state k* and y*]

Economy reaches steady state growth path (y*) corresponding to steady state level of capital (k*) corresponding to 's'. Now, if 's' increases to s1, then nation attains higher steady state equilibrium y*' :

[a graph of y against time with t1 and t2 marked: a rising curve that flattens to a higher level, the gap labelled level effect]

thus higher 's' only produces level effect.

It explains long run growth through Solow residual (SR) SR = ΔA = ΔY/y − α ΔK/K − β ΔL/L

[a growth diagram of y against k: curves y1=A1f(k) and y=A0f(k) with an upward arrow between them, a straight line labelled growth path, and curves sk and s1k]

S.R. increases the productivity of all FOP. s.t. it results in long term growth. S.R. shows sustained growth even at steady state.