Topper Copies

“Simplicity of the Quantity Theory of Money is its strength as well as its weakness.” Discuss.

Tanvi Gupta, AIR 187, 2024

Quantity Theory of Money (QTM) given by classicals state that there is a direct & proportionate relationship between Money supply (Ms) & price level (P).

It can be explained using Fisher's Transaction approach which is based on Fisher's equation of exchange MV = PY M = money supply V = velocity of circulation of money P = price level Y = real output.

Fisher assumes V & Y to be structural factors & hence constant in short run. Accordingly, MV̄ = PȲ shows direct & proportionate relation between Ms & P.

[a graph with price level P on the vertical axis and output Y on the horizontal axis, a vertical Ms line and downward-sloping curves AD'(M1,V) and AD(M0,V), with an arrow showing the shift from P0 to P1]

However, its weaknesses are : 1. It is based on mere truism (MV = PY) 2. It ignores interest elasticity of Md. 3. Keynes argued that Ms affects output & prices through interest-rate & not directly. 4. The Theory has been criticised for assuming V̄ to be constant. Because as Keynes showed V varies due to speculative Md.