Topper Copies

Give a theoretical analysis of the growth of the public expenditure in terms of Adolph Wagner's hypothesis. What are the criticisms levelled against it?

Tanvi Gupta, AIR 187, 2024

Alfred Wagner was the first economist to study & theorise the growth of public expenditure (P.E.) Wagner argued that the public expenditure has a tendency to increase with the increase in per capita income (PCY) He argued that the increase was not only in absolute terms but also in relative terms.

[a graph with P.E. on the vertical axis and PCY on the horizontal axis, a steeper convex curve labelled P.E. above a straight line labelled GDP/Y growth]

The elasticity of P.E. to PCY was found to be >1.

This was based on the analysis of Developed & Advanced economies. Thus, his approach was empirical in nature. (data of 19th & 20th c.) This, he argues, was due to both intensive & extensive expansion of public functions. - Intensive increase implies that govt. performs existing functions more intensively due to rising population, demand, etc. - Extensive increase implies that govt. expands its domain by performing new functions due to increasing inter linkages between public & private sector.

Wagner argues that this is a long term trend

Criticisms levelled against Wagner Hypothesis : 1. It is an empirical study & doesn't give theoretical explanation for the relationship between P.E. & PCY 2. It is based entirely on the study of Advanced economies & modern progressive govts.

However, the Wagner Hypothesis invoked greater interest in the study of public expenditure which led to advancements in the field like the Peacock-Wiseman Hypothesis which explained the Displacement & inspection effect of taxation.