In demand for money, what are the major differences between 'transaction approach' and 'cash balance approach'?
Tanvi Gupta, AIR 187, 2024
Money demand refers to the stock of money that the people want to hold in the form of cash. Classical Quantity Theory of Money has 2 versions - (A) Fisher's Transaction approach (B) Cambridge Approach. Both argue that there is a direct & proportionate relationship between money supply & price level. However, there are certain fundamental differences.
| TRANSACTION APPROACH | CAMBRIDGE APPROACH | |---|---| | 1. It is based on Fisher's Equation of Exchange MV̄ = PȲ<br>where V = Velocity of circulation of money<br>Y = real income<br>P = price level<br>M = money supply | 1. It states that people hold a proportion of nominal income in the form of cash<br>M = KPY<br>where K = prop. of money held as cash | | 2. It assumes V & Y to be constant in short run. | 2. It assumes K to be constant. | | 3. It determines money demand through relation between Ms & Md at equilibrium<br>Since Ms = PY/V<br>∴ Md = PY/V (at equilb)<br>[a graph of Md against PY/V, a straight line from the origin labelled Md = PY/V]<br>Thus, relationship of Md is indirectly determined | 3. It determines Md directly & stress on Md rather than Ms.<br>At equilibrium,<br>Md = Ms<br>∴ Ms = KPY<br>[a graph of Md against PY, a straight line from the origin labelled Md = KPY]<br>Relation of Md to Y is directly determined. | | 4. Focus is on money as a stock of value | 4. It focuses on money as a flow concept | | 5. Recognises the use of money only for transaction purpose | 5. It recognises the store of value function of money | | 6. It is mechanical in nature based on mere truism of Fisher's equation of exchange | 6. It is behavioral in nature as it captures the economic agents behaviours wrt Md. |
However, the classical QTM was later restated by Friedman who gave a portfolio Theory of Md by explicitly incorporating the interest elasticity of Md.