Distinguish between pure public goods, private goods and mixed goods. In which way can one achieve Pareto optimality when an economy provides private and public goods? Discuss.
Tanvi Gupta, AIR 187, 2024
The economic goods can be differentiated based on the 2 concepts of rivalry & excludability
| Pure public goods | private good | mixed goods | |---|---|---| | 1. Non-rival i.e. consumption by one person doesn't reduce availability to other. | 1. rival goods ∴ X = X_A + X_B | 1. can be rival (eg. externalities) or non-rival (eg. club goods) | | 2. non-excludable ↳ ∴ free ridership problem | 2. excludable based on price | 2. can be excludable based on membership | | 3. fully externalised | 3. fully internalised | 3. partly internalised | | 4. market fails. | 4. market works efficiently | 5. market fails. |
In case of market consisting of private as well as public goods, the pareto optimality conditions become different due to provision of public good which is equally available to all Samuelson gave the Pareto optimality condition to be : Maximisation of welfare of B, given the welfare of A. It exists when MRT = MRS^A_xy + MRS^B_xy
Model Assumption : 1. IC map of B is given 2. welfare of A is given 3. PPC is given.
[two graphs with X on the vertical axis and G on the horizontal axis: the upper with a concave PPC and the curve Ā, the lower with the residual curve and indifference curves IC_B1 and IC_B2 touching at E_II]
The availability of x & G to person B is determined by deducting the share of A from PPC. residual curve.
Thus, the availability curve of 'B' is a residual curve when G₁ of public good is produced, 'A' consumes entire good x ( private good ). Thus availability of x to B is zero. Similarly, when G₂ is produced, B gets zero good x. The pareto optimality exists where the ICs of B is targent to the residual curve i.e. at pt. E₁. At this pt. G* of public good is produced which is equally available to both A & B. And good x* private good is produced of which A get x_A* & B gets x_B*. Corresponding to this pt., MRT_xy = MRS^A_xy + MRS^B_xy
However, there exists a conflict Because increase in the Ā reduces availability curve of B. Similarly, increase in provision of 'G' reduces the availability of private good (x) due to resource constraint. Thus, a choice has to be made between G & X.