Discuss the determination of optimal provision of public good and the assignment of tax shares in the context of Lindahl-Johansen model.
Tanvi Gupta, AIR 187, 2024
The Lindahl - Johansen model of determination of optimal provision of public good & assignment of tax share is a part of " Benefits Pay Received principle " which states that taxation govt. is a part of voluntary exchange economy. Thus, taxation must be based on the benefits derived from govt. expenditure. There is quid pro quo. Lindahl - Johnson model determines not only the share of tax burden but also the optimal govt. expenditure & public good provision based on the utility derived by the taxpayers from public good provisioning.
[a boxed graph with tax share of B (O_B) down from the top and tax share of A (O_A) up from the bottom on the vertical axis, public good (G) on the horizontal axis, curves D_B and D_A meeting at E, dashed lines to T_E and G*]
Let there be 2 taxpayers - A & B. - The demand (dd) curve of A is convext to the origin (O_A) as the tax share of A increases, the demand for G reduces. - Similarly, D_B is the dd curve of B. It is convex to O_B. As B's tax share increases, his dd for G too reduces.
Accordingly, the equilibrium in the provision of public goods is determined where DA & DB intersect i.e at pt E.
Correspondingly, the public good G* is the optimal level which is available to both A & B equally as G is non-rival & non-excludable
However, the cost of provision of G* is shared by A & B. A's share is OA Te while B's share is OB Te. At this level of tax burden, both A & B derive same utility from public good.
however, the drawback of the model is that 1. Demand curve for public goods are difficult to determine ( free ridership ) 2. Ignores the principle of equity & ability to pay.