Topper Copies

Explain different version of equal sacrifice rule with the help of diagrams. Does equal sacrifice rule necessarily imply a progressive taxation?

Tanvi Gupta, AIR 187, 2024

The Theory of Incidence of Taxation studies about the burden distribution of taxation among different tax payers. It is the 'Ability to Pay' principle of Tax Incidence that argues that Tax is compulsory payment given to the govt. without any quid pro quo. Thus, it involves sacrifice is be made by the taxpayer. It is the Subjective approach of Ability to Pay Principle which states that the person with greater ability to pay must pay more based on sacrifice undergone by him. This helps in ensuring vertical equity.

equal Sacrifice Rule can be of different versions 1. equal absolute sacrifice - loss of TU (Total utility) of money must be same. 2. equal proportional sacrifice - ratio of loss of utility to TU must be same 3. equal Marginal sacrifice - it must be same at margin

explanation using Diagram

[two side-by-side downward-sloping curves, left for T with low y and right for R with higher y, with points P, Q, R, S on the left curve dropped to A, B, C, D on the axis and points P', Q', R', S' on the right curve dropped to A', B', C', D']

assumption 1. MU same for both 2. Total income (Y) = OA + OA'

In case of 1. equal absolute sacrifice Person T = ABQP R = A'B'Q'P' (equal) 2. Equal proportional sacrifice T = ACRP / AOMP is equal to R = A'CR'P' / A'OM'P' 3. equal marginal sacrifice T = SR = R = S'R'

equal sacrifice principle does not necessarily imply progressive taxation because. - in equal absolute sacrifice, the share of income paid as taxation by 'T' is more than that of 'R' - In equal Proportional sacrifice, both persons' position remains relative income same

Thus, Equal marginal sacrifice is most progressive while Equal Absolute sacrifice is least progressive of all & may even turn regressive.