Is Friedman's quantity theory of money close to Classical or Keynesian approach to the aggregate demand for money? Given justifications for your arguments.
Tanvi Gupta, AIR 187, 2024
Friedman gave the Restatement of Quantity Theory of money. His Money Demand (Md) theory is a portfolio theory which states that people hold money in the portfolio of assets like cash, bonds, debentures, etc.
The money demand (Md) i.e. the money that people are willing to hold in the form of cash thus depends on multiple factors 1. Total wealth of the economic agent. Permanent income (Yp) is taken as a proxy of wealth. 2. Ratio of human wealth (h) to total wealth 3. rate of return on bonds (rb), debentures (rd) & equity (re) 4. Price expectation of people (Pe)
Md = f(W, h, rb, rd, re, Pe)
Friedman argues that 'k' i.e. the proportion of wealth as cash is a stable function
k = f(rb, rd, re)
Thus Md = k.(PY)
The monetarist Theory has features of both classical & keynesian.
Similarities with keynes 1. It too accepts that Md is interest elastic.
However, it differs with keynes on following 1. Aggregate Md & not Component 2. K is stable & not variable. 3. Money supply affects Price level directly, rather than through 'r'.
Comparison with Classicals Similarities 1. K is stable 2. Md = KPY ( Cambridge equation) 3. Ms affects price level directly
However, differences are: 1. K is not constant 2. Relationship between Ms & P. is not equiproportional 3. Md is also interest elastic 4. Portfolio theory .
Thus, while Monetarist Theory of Md is an improvement over both Keynes & classicals, it is more closely linked to classical Theory.