Explain how Keynesian speculative demand for money is restated in regressive expectation model. Point out its limitations.
Tanvi Gupta, AIR 187, 2024
keynesian speculative demand for money (Msp) argues that people hold money to take advantage of fluctuations in money market s.t. Msp is inversely related to 'r' (interest rate) It is linked to Regressive Expectations model which states that- 1. If interest rate is higher than normal, people expect it to reduce in future, accordingly Msp reduces as people will buy bonds today If interest rate is lower than normal, people expect it to rise in future. Thus Msp rises. 2. The return on cash is zero. 3. The return on bond is equal to bond yield (Y)/ interest rate (r) & capital gain (g) due to changes in price of bond. (Pb)
Model ∴ return on bond = r + g ( r = Y/Pb )
g = (Pb^e - Pb)/Pb = (Y/r^e - Y/r)/(Y/r) = (1/r^e - 1/r)/(1/r) g = r/r^e - 1
The total return on bond = r + g = r + r/r^e - 1
At critical r (r_c) ⇒ return on cash & bond is equal & are indifferent. 0 = r + r/r^e - 1 ∴ r_c = r^e/(r^e + 1)
[a graph with r on the vertical axis and M/P on the horizontal axis, a horizontal line at r_c, the region above it labelled r>r_c and the boxed region below it labelled r<r_c]
- for all r > r_c, people buy only bonds - If r < r_c, people hold only cash.
Aggregating the different values of r_c for different individuals, downward sloping Md based on regressive expectations is obtained
[a graph with r on the vertical axis and M/P on the horizontal axis, a downward-sloping curve from r_c max to a dashed line at r_c min, labelled Aggregate Md]
Limitations 1. It is backward looking as agents form expectations based on past behaviour 2. It is based on pure portfolio model wherein people hold either only cash or only bonds. However, in reality people hold both cash & bonds.