Topper Copies

Assess the impact of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) on India's federal fiscal relations.

Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024

101st Amendment introduced GST as the single indirect tax system in India - for aim of One Nation One Tax.

Impact of GST on India's federal fiscal relations: 1. GST Council provides common platform to enable centre-state collaboration. 1.1) states have 2/3rd majority and a decision needs 3/4th majority - Thus giving states a large voice in decisions. 1.2) council sets broad rates band and allow states the fiscal space to tinker with the rates. 2. Simple market - GST has removed tax differentials and enabled cooperative federalism among states. 3. Higher tax buoyancy enables greater tax collection and devolution. 4. Destination - based tax nature of GST benefits state with larger demand - thus ensuring horizontal equity.

[a line graph, "Fig : Monthly GST revenue", crore against 2018, 2019, 2020, rising through 0.9, 1 and 1.2]

5. Higher Inter - state trade enabled by removing tax - differentials and cascading - effect of taxes.

But, GST also hampers fiscal federalism in some ways:- 1. Loss of tax autonomy of states - under VAT they had control over state taxes, now lost. 2. Debate over compensation beyond 5 years to ensure revenue neutrality for states. 3. Delay in devolution of state share hampers fiscal relations. 4. High revenue states lost due to fall in effective indirect tax rate from (15%) to (12%) under GST - 5. No dispute resolution mechanism for centre - state GST disputes

Way Ahead 1. Ensure timely devolution of state shares - 2. GST Tribunal and Appellate Board to be made functional at the earliest. 3. Ensure all states representatives attend GST council meetings, without skipping. 4. Decide on continuance of compensation cess with state consensus.

GST can become a good & simple tax for balancing fiscal federalism in India.