Discuss the challenges and opportunities of transitioning from central planning to indicative planning in India.
Apoorva Agrawal, AIR 65, 2024
India transformed from central to indicative planning from 8th FYP (1992 - 1997) onwards, in the backdrop of 1991 LPG reforms.
Challenges of transitioning from central to indicative planning in India 1. Reduce state support to the weaker sectors and sections, for eg: Public GCF in agriculture fell from 50% in 1980 to 16% in 2000. 2. Inequality rose due to concentration of wealth with private players → share of top 1% in income is 27% as per Oxfam. 3. Dichotomy of development - Ren & Dreze point that state correctly identified too much govt. interference in some sectors, but ignored too little govt. support in other sectors (education, health, etc) 4. Market failures like under-production of public goods, pollution externalities, etc .
Opportunities of transition from central to indicative planning in India 1. growth took off after 1990 due to private sector participation - rose from (5.2%) to (7%) in 1990s [Vijay Joshi, 2016] 2. Poverty reduction from (45%) in 1993 to (21.9%) by 2011 [Tendulkar committee Report] 3. Service boom - IT - BPO, hardware & software services, etc have enabled service exports - making [?]% of global trade
[a line graph, "Fig: share of service trade", x-axis 1950, 1990, 2020, rising line through 0.5%, 2% and 4%]
4. Innovation - India has become 3rd largest startup ecosystem in world. 5. global enterprises like TATA, Infosys, Wipro etc took off. 6. Private sector in social services to complement state - 60% health-care & 30% education catered by private sector.
From indicative planning, India is further transitioning to market - based planning for the 21st century.