Topper Copies

The booklet prints no question (question 5(b)); the answer is written to the question of what the consumption puzzle is and how the Permanent Income Hypothesis explains it.

Dipti Ranjan Pati, AIR 164, 2024

The consumption puzzle refers to the observation that as consumption shows the following properties - (i) mpc < APC in cross-sections (ii) mpc < APC across business cycle. (iii) But mpc = APC in the long run.

Permanent Income Hypothesis by milton Friedman seeks to explain all of these properties. → Income y_i = y_i^p + y_i^t . —(i) Where y_i^p → permanent income y_i^t → transitory income. Permanent income y_i^p = k_i(PV_i), i.e., it is a fraction of the present value of income streams at the current period. → Consumption c_i = c_i^p + c_i^t —(ii) c_i^p → Permanent Consumption c_i^t → Transitory Consumption.

Friedman's assumptions (i) Cov (y_i^P, y_i^t) = 0 (ii) Cov (c_i^P, c_i^t) = 0 (iii) Cov (y_i^t, c_i^t) = 0

-> Since transitory consumption is un-correlated with transitory income as well as too permanent consumption, for a given income class 'j', C̄_j^t = 0, so that C̄_j = C̄_j^P -> Transitory consumption = random fluctuation

-> Now, if a sample of the population is arranged in terms of income, an income class with higher income than average has ȳ_j^t > 0 and so, ȳ_j > ȳ_j^P.

[a graph of C against y, with a 45-degree line OX and a flatter line AB crossing it, and dotted guide lines to the y axis]

-> Along the line OX, C̄_P = ȳ_P, i.e., transitory income & consumption on average is zero; this explains the long run constancy of C/Y.

-> However, across cross-sections & business cycles, the relevant line is AB, which clearly gives MPC < APC since C̄/ȳ is lower for higher income classes & higher for lower classes.