The booklet prints no question (question 4(c)); the answer is written to the question of what economic rent and transfer earnings are, with diagrams, and how they behave in the long run.
Dipti Ranjan Pati, AIR 164, 2024
[a supply and demand graph, Fig 1, with the area above the supply line marked Economic Rent and the area below it Transfer Earnings, points D, C, E on the axes]
Economic rent arises whenever supply of a factor is less than completely elastic.
→ It is the surplus over and above the transfer earnings.
eg- SPBE in Fig 1.
The Transfer Earnings are the necessary remuneration that must be given to a factor to keep it in the production of the current commodity, due to the presence of alternative uses.
→ the area DEBC represents transfer earnings in Fig 1.
Long run If in the long-run, the supply of the factor becomes elastic; then transfer earnings may disappear as alternative uses become rare.
[a graph, Fig 2, of a downward sloping line meeting a horizontal supply line at e, with a shaded rectangle labelled Rent]
The entire area Pefg is economic rent in Fig 2.
However, if a factor remains scarce in supply even in the long run, such as land, it will earn only partial rent as the rest constitutes transfer earning.