Topper Copies

Assess the impact of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) on India's federal fiscal relations.

Tanvi Gupta, AIR 187, 2024

India introduced GST through 101st Constitutional amendment Act. It marked a shift towards creation of single uniform market.

However, GST regime changed the Federal Fiscal relations :

Positive Impact on Fiscal relations

1. Creation of 3-tier system based on CGST, SGST and IGST. Increased uniformity and Fiscal Federalism. 2. GST council was regarded as the Fiscal Federal technology by ES 2017. Increased cooperation between centre and state on sitting of tax rates, etc.

However, there were certain negative impact too.

1. Rao 2022 : The Tax - State GDP ratio of non special category states reduced from 8.5 % to 6.4 %. 2. It subsumed Sales tax which accounted for 60 % of the state revenue. 3. The GST Council voting share gives centre a virtual veto over council decisions. As wth states have 2/3rd voting share but the quorum required is 3/4 th. 4. Shortfall in the GST Compensation Fund of ₹ 2.3 lakh crore has led to loss to state revenue and conflict between centre and states over due compensation.

Indian GST tried to resolve the issues due to its sui-generis system based on 1. Revenue neutrality by keeping 4 tax rates ( 5%, 12%, 18% and 28%) to ensure adequate revenue to states. 2. Excluding taxes on crude oil, petrol, diesel, alcohol from the GST regime.

There is a need of rationalising the rates further and compensating the states adequately for any shortfall, to strengthen fiscal federalism in post GST regime.