Topper Copies

Examine the implications of the 73rd and 74th Constitutional amendments on decentralized planning in India.

Tanvi Gupta, AIR 187, 2024

The 73rd and 74th constitutional Amendment Act provided for local-self-governance, based on the Gandhian philosophy of village republics.

Positive Implications

1. Principle of Subsidiarity was adopted to increase efficiency by undertaking planning and execution based on efficiency factor - 2. Facilitated macro planning and micro implementation of policies. Thus, adjusting policies according to local demands. 3. Social audit of schemes by Gram sabhas insures transparency and accountability of government. 4. Increases women-empowerment as 33% of the seats are reserved for women. 5. It has synergies with Indian Foreign Trade Policy (2023) that aims to establish Districts as Export Hubs. Ex one District, one Product Scheme. 6. It has social spillovers. Ex Pimpri Chinchwad launched 1st social impact Bonds.

Negatives and Issues that remain to be addressed.

1. Lack of adequate Finance to local governments. 95% of funds to PRIs are tied funds 2. Inadequate democratic decentralisation as states have been reluctant to devolve functions to the local govts. 3. Manishankar Aiyar Committee : There has been decentralisation of corruption. 4. Lack of training of local staff. and infrastructural gaps. 5. Setting up of parallel institutions in the form of SPVs has led to overshadowing of local govts. 6. The problem of Panchpati and political interference has prevented effective governance at local level.

Thus, as 2nd ARC recommended, local govts must be allowed to raise their own funds (like Muni bonds) and effective decentration of functions must be done by states to ensure Antyodaya se Sarvodaya.