Topper Copies

Compare the Kaldor-hicks criterion with the pareto criterion in assessing changes in welfare due to a new policy.

Polavarapu Dhwanish, AIR 108, 2025

Pareto efficiency criteria mentions that the optimum welfare situation is where no one can be made better off without making someone worse off.

Kaldor-Hicks compensation criteria attempted to overcome a limitation of Pareto efficiency where a social change that makes someone better off and other worse off is carried out. In this case, Kaldor-Hicks came up with compensation criteria, according to which; if a social change is such that a gainer gains enough to compensate the loser for their loss, then such social change is desirable.

[a graph of a utility possibility frontier with U_A on the horizontal axis and U_B on the vertical axis, with points A, N and Q]

As observed in the diagram, if due to social change, utility changes such that economy B moves from M to Q, then in this case while A gains as its utility increases from U_1A to U_2A, but B loses, as its utility decreases from U_1B to U_2B.

In this case, A can compensate B for its loss by moving from Q to N, thus restoring its old utility level at U_1B, while still being in a better position at U_3A than U_1A. Therefore, according to Kaldor-Hicks criteria such social change is desirable.

Kaldor-Hicks attempted to bring changes in decision making criteria for policy changes by: 1. Attempting to separate distribution function from production problem, which cannot be done. 2. Bring in a new criteria for welfare, by evaluating social welfare policies through a different perspective than Pareto optimality criteria. 3. Helping in decision making in cases where a social change may lead to betterment for some and may leave others worse off, like expanding a railway station at the cost of slum dwellers.