The booklet prints no question for this answer; it is written to the question of how Ricardo's and Kalecki's theories of distribution compare.
Polavarapu Dhwanish, AIR 108, 2025
Ricardo and Kalecki provided alternate theories of distribution. while Ricardo focused on marginal and surplus principle, Kalecki's explanation relied on monopoly power of firms.
| | Ricardo theory | Kalecki Theory | |---|---|---| | 1 | According to Ricardian theory state of technology is given | Kalecki makes no assumption about state of technology | | 2 | An economy is producing only one good | while there exists multiple players producing different goods, according to Kalecki, profitability depends on Monopoly power of firms | | 3 | There are only two cost- labour and wage and land rent | Kalecki makes no assumption about costs and factors of production | | 4 | Capital accumulation is a result of accumulating profits | Kalecki's theory suggests that it is the monopoly power of firm that determines its proportion in distribution and thereby capital accumulation | | 5 | Ultimately due to rising wages and declining profits, economy reaches stagnancy | Kalecki does not suggest economic stagnancy in the long run | | 6 | Since, all players are producing corn, and individual production units behave as single large entity, they are taken as one unit of production | According to Kalecki, there may exist multiple players in the market producing same or differentiated products | | 7 | Profitability depends upon wages, and price of corn | Profitability depends upon monopoly power of firm to charge price above marginal costs. |
however, both models suggest that capital accumulation / rising profits leads to higher investments thereby leading to larger outputs.
Thus, both models have different approaches to theorize distribution. however, Ricardo's model seems to be more hypothetical with its radical assumptions like single product production; free hand of the market and negligence of all institutional factors.